Nudging Obama

Formerly "Obama Watch" Keeping the promise of change

New President, Old Immigration Policy

with one comment

Dissident Voice: a radical newsletter in the struggle for peace and social justice

Voices of Color

New President, Old Immigration Policy

Some prominent immigrant rights organizations sincerely hoped that electing Obama would turn things around for immigrants. But those hopes were misplaced. Obama’s policies mirror those of his predecessors: more raids, detentions, and deportations; more roadblocks to citizenship; and more pandering to the right wing.

Fortunately, though, the cause of immigrants rights is still alive at the grass roots.

Updating the harassment.

Bill Clinton took militarization of the U.S.-Mexico border to a new level. His buildup has caused many immigrants to lose their lives by crossing at the physically harsh, but less patrolled, Arizona border. George W. Bush expanded upon what Clinton initiated.

Obama is on the same track. In April, his administration announced plans to expand a $1.1 billion program to check the immigration status of everyone arrested for a crime. This Bush-era policy broadens the power of local authorities to enforce federal law.

Obama intends to further develop Bush’s “zero tolerance” program, which puts undocumented immigrants caught crossing the border into detention. He will also continue to put billions toward more border patrol and the construction of high-tech “security fence” dividing people along the border.

During the Bush years, workplace raids increased dramatically. While these are still happening, Obama has announced a shift in focus to the prosecution of employers who hire unauthorized workers. This puts pressure on employers to participate in the mostly voluntary E-Verify system, which became mandatory for federal subcontractors on Sept. 8.

E-Verify checks the immigration status of potential workers by way of a federal database (which is acknowledged to flag huge numbers of people who are actually authorized to work in the U.S.). E-Verify loss of employment is not as visible as armed raids, but it has the same results. Obama wants the program to become mandatory for all employers.

Under Obama, just one division of Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE), the Flight Operations Unit, is deporting an average of 4,200 immigrants every week, up from 3,700 last year.

Accommodating to the racist right wing.

Like Bush, Obama says he believes that undocumented people in the U.S. who want legal status should go to the back of a very long, extremely slow line, behind people applying while still in their home countries.

He also has said that applicants must learn English. Although most immigrants acquire enough English to get by, many do not have the time or resources to take classes. Learning English should remain a voluntary learning skill, not an unconstitutional requirement.

Additionally, Obama wants immigrants to pay fines and back taxes as part of gaining legal resident status — which puts this goal out of reach for most immigrants.

Obama is silent about the devastating free-trade policies that force immigrants to come to the U.S. just to survive. And he has nothing to say from his presidential bully pulpit about the anti-immigrant racism that is directed today primarily toward Latin Americans from many quarters, including media blights like CNN’S Lou Dobbs. Instead, the president caters to anti-immigrant sentiment.

This was obvious in his Sept. 9 healthcare speech, when he sternly reassured Congress that his plan would not cover “illegals” — deliberately adopting the right wing’s term. This validates the racist myth that immigrant workers deplete tax dollars when, in truth, immigrants contribute more than their fair share.

Where to look for change?

The economy is in a perpetual state of crisis — poverty, sexist and racist inequality, declining profits, unemployment, foreclosures — none of which are the fault of immigrants! But Democratic politicians, just like Republicans, will do whatever they can to bail out their profit system.

Throwing money at big corporations to build and secure borders or run private immigration detention centers is one strategy. Another is to ensure the flow of cheap labor. Accordingly, it would not be surprising should Obama follow in the Clinton/Bush footsteps by calling for some sort of “guest-worker” bill — in reality, legislation for indentured servitude.

Obama is obligated to act in the interest of the business elite, making unlikely any moratorium on raids, detentions, and deportations — much less unconditional amnesty, open borders, or the dismantling of ICE. The moral of the story: support for Democrats needs to end in favor of political parties that actually represent the needs of workers, truly independent from both parties of big business.

Look too toward a bold immigrant rights movement to turn things around. The power of such a movement shone through during the 1996 student walkouts and big marches, which prevented the imminent enactment of a guest-worker bill and greatly increased solidarity for immigrants by organized labor. Many specific acts of resistance are keeping the spirit of that movement alive today.

Community organizations across the U.S. have staged protests against raids. In Washington state, groups protested an ICE raid at an auto parts factory. In California, residents at the Woodlawn Mobile Home Park demanded an end to police brutality against immigrants who are fellow residents. In Ohio, a group rallied against raids at Casa Fiesta restaurants.

The Stop the Checkpoints coalition in western Washington state has mobilized hundreds against border patrol checkpoints and immigration raids. Their organizing led the local sheriff to announce that his office will not cooperate with Homeland Security.

In Texas, several protests took place outside the T. Don Hutto facility, a private detention center that also jailed young children. It was recently announced that families will no longer be held at this notorious prison.

Obama will never deliver on immigrant rights. That’s a job for immigrants themselves, unionists, socialists, and other social-change groups, united in a common struggle to “lift all boats” by providing justice and fairness for those on the bottom.

  • This article first appeared in Freedom Socialist newspaper, Vol. 30, No. 5, October-November 2009.
  • Christina López is a Seattle Radical Women Organizer. She can be reached at: Read other articles by Christina.


    Written by bearmarketnews

    October 8, 2009 at 10:45 pm

    Posted in Uncategorized

    One Response

    Subscribe to comments with RSS.

    1. The House-Senate committees has completed its funding in the Homeland Security Appropriations bill as of yesterday, undermining long-term security of unemployed American workers. They omitted the language that would have implemented the E-Verify application on a permanent basis to eject illegal workers. Instead, the conference extended the agreement limits of reauthorization for just three years. Even as E-Verify is gaining in nationwide popularity in businesses, the politicians are still catering to illegal immigrants. A assessment to extend E-Verify for only three more years is further evidence that Sen. Reid and the administration's effort, to raise a façade, but all the while dismantling effectual controls against immigration invasion. So although the open border organization, headed by quasi-leadership of the Council of Foreign Relations, US Chamber of Commerce and anti American organizations such as the ACLU, La Raza didn't win in Federal Court they still determined to corrode the laws.These special interest lobbyists are well organized in the Democratic Senate and House to undermine any enforcement of immigration laws, including the 1986 (IRCA) that is a law that was never enforced. Same day Sen.David Vitter offered an amendment to sever Federal funds to SANCTUARY CITIES AND STATES, but as always they failed to observe the "Rule of Law." The vote went along party lines except for three Republicans who voted with the Democrats to table the amendment. One Democrat voted against the motion – Landrieu (LA). Even though we can throw the conspirators out, when they come up for re-election it will have little effect? Even though they lose their seats, they will be reimbursed by their corporate friends with nice civilian desk jobs, with bloated pay checks.NUMBERSUSA is an American people’s website that removes the propaganda placed on us by the Liberal press. At this location is raw evidence–YOU NEED TO KNOW–of the Democratic Leadership who is conspiring with industry, so that millions of illegal immigrants can still cross the border, so they can feed like leeches from American taxpayers and take the jobs. Everything you need to know about corrupted officials, mayor’s judges, governors and politicians is available at JUDICIAL WATCH. Learn where billions of dollars are going for undisclosed welfare programs for illegal aliens and families. Go to these websites and become a political advocate and keep the names of each treacherous politician in your long term memory.Throw out Sen. Harry Reid, as he has been in the forefront of de-funding, derailing all the active laws such as 287 G. Janet Napolitano should join him on the garbage heap, along with speaker Pelosi who has an (F-) in immigration grading for enforcement. Mark your own lawmaker and drag him across the hot coals by calling 202-224-3121 Find out the buried truth at NUMBERSUSA, JUDICIAL WATCH & CAPSWEB, for overpopulation facts. They even went after Sheriff Joe Ariapo in Arizona for carrying out his duties, under the 287 G fed law. His deputies were so successful in the removal program; big business went crawling to the Democratic leaders pleading for assistance. GET THE FACTS–NOT THE LIES! REMEMBER NO TAXPAYER HEALTH CARE FOR FOREIGN NATIONALS! NO AMNESTY! NO NOTHING! THEY BROKE OUR LAWS OF SOVEREIGNTY!


      October 8, 2009 at 11:50 pm

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

    You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


    Connecting to %s

    %d bloggers like this: